Using our new IPC200 EUI test
bench we tested several injectors. All of these were
Detroit Diesel Series 60 injectors, and they included some of
our own remanufactured injectors, as well as some that we
purchased from different sources. These injectors were not
all the same part number.
We do not claim to be the only source of a quality
remanufactured EUI's, and this was not the purpose of this report.
However, we were surprised by some of the results and feel that
our new IPC200 test bench has defiantly taken the EUI testing
process to a new level! Since this report is
obviously biased, it is only fair that negative sources are also
anonymous.
The first injector we tested for this report was an OEM
Reliabilt™ injector.
Our primary purpose in testing this injector was to verify the
results that we were receiving from our test bench, and this
injector proved to be of good quality. This is something
we have come to expect from the OEM, and in this case we were
not disappointed. Our goal is to provide an injector
equivalent to this one, but at a better price! The test
results for this injector are shown below:
Since in most cases a new OEM injector is our standard
(assuming it tests ok), we will use the results from this
injector as our standard for the other injectors we tested in
this report.
The second injector we tested was produced by a major
aftermarket supplier. They remanufacture these injectors
in their own facilities, and supply them through their own
distribution network. We do not know what processes and/or
equipment they use for final testing. Here are the test
results:
These results surprised us, since we expected better!
This injector has very close to the proper fuel flows and the
response time is a little slow (compare the first arc in this
curve to the same curve in the Reliabilt™
graph). This injector has serious issues with PIP (Peak
Injection Pressure). To be fair, we only had a single
injector to test, so this injector may not be representative of
the overall quality of Series 60 injectors remanufactured by
this supplier.
This injector would not have caused any serious problems with
the engine, nor would it have triggered any fault codes to be
set by the ECM (Engine Control Module). It would however
have an effect on overall performance and fuel economy.
We plan to return this injector as defective!
The third injector came from another fuel injection shop.
We are not sure if they even test them. After our testing
was complete, we disassembled this injector, and it
appeared that the only new and/or remanufactured parts used were
the o-rings. Based on these findings, the test results
were to be expected. It is almost impossible to produce a
quality EUI without an extensive investment in time, tools,
people, parts and equipment!
This injector would have caused some serious problems.
If installed, it would have resulted in fault codes being set by
the ECM, and this engine would have had significant power,
performance and fuel economy issues. We had 6 these
injectors for testing, and 4 out of 6 tested the same or worse
than this one. Two of the injectors from this set tested
ok, with the exception of the 500 RPM fuel flows which were too
high.
The last injector we tested for this report was one that had
been remanufactured by us ... actually we tested 3 of them at a
time, two of them passed and the third did not. This test
report shown below is one of the two that passed all the tests.
The injector that did NOT pass all the tests had low fuel
delivery at higher speeds, and the PIP was at the low side of
the acceptable limit. Further investigation revealed that
the poppet valve had a small leak which was NOT detected during
the process of remanufacturing the injector. This is why
we use equipment such as the IPC200, and that particular
injector would never be sent to a customer.
The injector shown in this report passed all the tests, and
the pressure graphs are the same as a new OEM injector.
This is an injector that we can confidently put into service,
knowing that it meets or exceeds OEM specifications. |